Jose Baxter scored two penalties with Che Adams also converting a spot-kick. Matt Done and Stefan Scougall were United's other scorers while Jon Stead netted County's consolation.
Baxter opened the scoring from the spot in the 20th minute after Jamal Campbell-Ryce was fouled by Thierry Audel.
Liam Noble went close to equalising when his lob beat goalkeeper George Long, only for the ball to come back off the bar.
Oldham sign former United trainee Eckersley
Done made it 2-0 in the 23rd minute when he found himself one-on-one with Loach and dinked the ball over the keeper.
Baxter scored his second penalty on 36 minutes after Haydn Hollis fouled Adams.
Substitute Stead pulled a goal back for Notts shortly after the hour, bundling the ball in from close range after meeting a low cross from Elliott Hewitt.
Scougall restored United's three-goal advantage in the 67th minute with a neat finish from inside the area.
On 74 minutes, Adams completed the scoring with another penalty after being hauled down by Hollis, who was sent off as a result.
Tuesday's JPT results
Bristol Rovers 2-0 Wycombe
Bury 0-1 Morecambe
Bradford P-P Barnsley
Crawley 0-3 Southend
Crewe 2-3 Wigan
Fleetwood 2-1 Shrewsbury
Gillingham 2-1 Luton
Millwall 2-0 Northampton
Oxford 2-0 Swindon
Plymouth 2-0 Exeter
Port Vale 1-2 Blackpool
Rochdale 2-1 Chesterfield
Sheffield United 5-1 Notts County
Yeovil 0-0 Coventry (pens: 4-3)
York 2-0 Doncaster
Tomori set for Milan switch, West Ham eye Serie A star Zapata - Transfer Notebook
'A lot of targets' - Tuchel relishing Chelsea run-in