The 25-year-old American breezed to a 6-2 6-2 win over the outplayed Italian, claiming the first two games in both sets to set the tone.
Watch tennis on Eurosport and on the Eurosport Player
After Giorgi fought back to 3-2 in the first set, Pegula took the next three games as the Italian's errors mounted in the 59-minute match.
ATP Metz
'My tennis is getting better' - Murray feeling good as he sets up Moselle Open quarter-final
The second set was even more one-sided as Pegula marched to a 5-1 advantage before Giorgi, on the comeback trail after wrist and ankle injuries, won a second game.
Pegula, the daughter of the owners of the National Football League's Buffalo Bills and National Hockey League's Buffalo Sabres, closed out the match with a stunning service winner and sank to her knees in celebration.
She won 81% of her first serves and saved the only break point she faced against the former Wimbledon quarter-finalist.
“I’ve always played so well here,” Pegula told the crowd afterwards.
“So I’m so happy I can get my first title here.”
WTA Indian Wells
Osaka withdraws from Indian Wells
Highlights: Murray beats Pospisil to make Metz quarter-finals